From ‘Nazi’ to saviour in a couple of weeks: the flip-flopping of Michael Gove

Janet Downs's picture

Experts who warned Brexit could cause economic problems were described by Michael Gove as being like the Nazi scientists paid by Hitler’s government to denounce Einstein.  One of these experts was Mark Carney, Bank of England governor.

But in his leadership bid speech, Gove praised the man he had smeared:

‘I want in particular to pay tribute to the Governor of the Bank of England for making it clear that Britain is prepared for this transition.’

Mark Carney could be forgiven for rolling his eyesHe warned there could be a financial mess if the UK voted to leave the EU.   Gove called him a Nazi for doing so.  But now Carney is no longer a Fascist in government pay.  He is a saviour for having the prescience to compile a post-Referendum plan should the UK vote to leave – a plan aimed at minimising any mess which might follow if the Referendum vote went Gove’s way.

But at least Carney had a planGove’s speech was long on emotion, beliefs and visions but short on what he would actually do.   He presented an extensive list of what ‘We’ need:  ‘bold leadership’; ‘change’, ‘radicalism and ambition’.  But firm promises were few: cut VAT on domestic fuel; at least another £100 million per week for the NHS by 2020, stop free movement and (here’s a surprise) take us out of the EU.  

It’s not the first time Gove has flip-flopped:

  • The experts he chose for the National Curriculum Review would be ‘innovative and inspiring education academics.’  But they disagreed with him and were denounced as professors toadying favour with the Labour party. 
  • He was forced to retract his statement during the Referendum campaign that the UK would not have left the EU by 2020.   
  • In 2012 he said he was ‘open-minded’ about allowing England’s schools to be run for profit.  But two years previously, he’d made up his mind.  He told Policy Exchange he would let groups like Serco run schools.

Finally, there’s the flip-flop described as treacherous: Gove’s last-minute decision that Boris Johnson was unfit for leadership.  But David Laws, in his book Coalition, reveals that Johnson’s flakiness was apparent in 2012.  He describes (pp165-6) an Education Reform summit hosted by Gove.  The Spanish education minister, who was in conversation with Laws, introduced herself to Johnson.  When she told him where she came from, Johnson said how Brussels was one of his favourite places.  The Spanish minister asked Johnson if he’d actually visited Spain.  ‘Ah, Spain? Spain... I must have been there!  Hot, isn’t it?  Yes, very, very hot!’  Johnson then left her to pose for a selfie with a star-struck young teacher.  Later, Johnson made a speech in which he ‘systematically’ insulted most of London’s population.

Gove may not have witnessed Johnson’s gaffe with the Spanish minister, but he would have heard his speech.  And it’s highly likely he would have read Laws’ book.  This undermines Gove’s claim he was unaware of Johnson’s personality faults until just before Johnson was due to announce his leadership bid.

A flip-flopping prime minister, one who switches from fulsome praise to name-calling (or vice-versa), one whose behaviour has cast doubts on his integrity and one who has attracted accusations of plotting and intrigue, is not one with the qualities to lead the UK.


Share on Twitter Share on Facebook

Be notified by email of each new post.


trevor fisher's picture
Mon, 04/07/2016 - 11:50

we seem to be ignoring Dominic Cummings. His comment on Cameron cited in the summer quiz should be treasured. Gove has a double back stabbing record, as Cameron twice promoted him. But Mr Cumming's career mirrors that of his master.

He is Sancho Panza to Gove's Don Quiote. Who actually ran the official leave campaign? It was a lovingly crafted knife Gove stuck in Cameron's back. But who crafted it?

The Goviate is a collective, It is not just one man.

Trevor Fisher

Janet Downs's picture
Mon, 04/07/2016 - 12:23

You're right that the Gove Project is not Gove alone.  The DT lists what it calls 'the cukoo's nest plotters' who had a hand in Boris's downfall: Gove, his wife Sarah Vine, Cameron, Osborne, minister Nick Boles, and Dominic Cummings.   It's an interesting theory - that Cameron and Osborne were complicit in Gove's plans.  I'm not entirely convinced that Cameron would wish to see Gove as PM - Laws' book describes how the DfE under Gove undermined Cameron.  The PM had complained to Nick Clegg that the education department could become 'a totally dysfunctional department'.  According to Laws, Cameron regretted that he didn't get Gove to sack Cummings after the Building Schools for the Future debacle because 'Cummings has a Rasputin-like influence on Michael - and it's all for the worse'.

Boris's sister suggests Gove is in his thrall to his wife.  She's already been described as a Lady Macbeth.  This is another reason to consider Gove to be unsuitable for the job of PM - inclined to be influenced by both a wild-eyed consigliere and an ambitious wife. 

agov's picture
Tue, 05/07/2016 - 12:45

I'll put you down as a Gove 'maybe' then.

Meanwhile, Governor Carney has been warning that households with too much debt may be exposed to market changes. Shocker.

Add new comment

Already a member? Click here to log in before you comment. Or register with us.