Accountable for some, responsible for all

Fiona Millar's picture
I have got an article in today's Guardian about how schools, including academies, are forging new relationships with their local authorities and with each other. My piece also poses the question of why we need to re-invent a 'middle tier'  when, as the Leader of Lambeth Council Steve Reed points out "We don't need to create a new middle tier. We already have one and its called the local authority."

Sadly too late for my piece, I received an e-mail from Helen Anthony, head teacher of the high performing and very popular  Fortismere School in the  more affluent part of the London Borough of Haringey. She wanted to tell me about how passionately heads in her area were about working collaboratively to support all children in their area, not just their own. More evidence that in the face of a nationally led drive for a more fragmented school system, institutions on the ground are actively seeking to create strong, accountable community links.

In particular Mrs Anthony wanted to tell me about how strongly she felt about the way students from the less well -heeled parts of Haringey have been demonised by both media and politicians following the riots last summer and the forced acadamisation of several primary schools when , as she put it: " the young people of Haringey have the right to live and learn without having to deal with the additional stigma of being Haringey residents in general and Tottenham specifically as presented in the press time after time. "

Earlier this year Mrs Anthony wrote to her own school community along the same lines in a newsletter which read:" I am really saddened every time I read yet another negative article about Haringey in general and Tottenham specifically and can only assume that the ‘outside world’s’ view of our special corner of London must be very tainted by now. Readers of the TES (Times Educational Supplement) will have become almost immune to the weekly stories about Downhills Primary and the fact that time and time again, Gove has placed Haringey firmly on the ‘naughty steps’!

"Is this really it? Is Haringey always to be judged guilty until proven innocent? Are we, the people of Haringey, prepared to sit back and let our reputation be dragged through the ‘mud’ in this way time and time again?

"As we approach the anniversary of the events that shocked and saddened Tottenham’s community and indeed the whole country, we are mindful of the damage that did to peoples’ lives, children’s futures and yes, our collective reputation as Haringey residents. My fellow Secondary Head colleagues and I have talked a great deal about the many successes in terms of results, Ofsted inspections and the countless other successes of the students and staff it is our privilege to work with but where is the media coverage of this?"

Now Haringey Secondary Heads , four of whom run outstanding schools, have now adopted the mantra "accountable for some, responsible for all". And at  Gladesmore Community School in Tottenham ( also an outstanding school)  head Tony Hartney and his  students have put together a song "Everybody Dreams" , which will be released in August, to try and show a positive side to the area which they love .

The song is being actively promoted by Fortismere because Helen Anthony believes that students and residents in her more leafy part of the borough have a "moral duty" to support all students in Haringey. This chimes with comments made in my Guardian piece today by Alan Wood, now Director of Children's Services in Hackney but who, for the last ten years, has overseen stunning improvements in one of the most deprived boroughs in the country as Chief Executive of the Learning Trust which took over Hackney education just over ten years ago.

Wood has a similar expression he uses about the mix of Hackney academy and non academy schools " They may not be our schools, but they are still our children."When I was writing the article he told me: "Local authorities that are actively trying to push their schools out and relinquish their role are in my view not confident about their moral purpose and responsibility".

In their small way comments like these make me optimistic that, out of the chaos that the government seems hell-bent on creating, a new order will emerge in which people can celebrate success jointly and re-discover that  together we can achieve more than we can alone.Do please  watch out for and spread the word about the Gladesmore song. It is a dream worth believing in.




Share on Twitter Share on Facebook

Be notified by email of each new post.


Janet Downs's picture
Wed, 20/06/2012 - 06:38

It's depressing that in areas where central co-ordination is needed most, ie rural counties, schools are opting for academy status. It's difficult to share practice when schools are many miles apart - this is made more difficult when academies are isolated institutions counting every penny of their budgets. It's here where local authorities are useful - organising the time and place for professional development (and paying travelling expenses).

However, in Lincolnshire, the county council is shedding responsibility for its schools and has recommended they all convert to academies preferably with its preferred provider CfBT. Of course, CfBT will provide professional development for staff in its schools but this is unlikely to be accessed by Lincolnshire academies linked to other chains such as the rapidly growing Greenwood Dale Foundation Trust. This splitting of schools from the centralised local authority risks further fragmentation in an area where secondary schools are already divided by selection.

Ricky-Tarr's picture
Wed, 20/06/2012 - 15:06

Short version of the OP:

Academies can and do cooperate with other schools and their LAs and have become good citizens in their local communities - just as Michael Gove always said they would...... something LSN commenters and posters always said wouldn't happen.

Janet Downs's picture
Wed, 20/06/2012 - 16:20

Ricky - I think we've had this discussion before. Only 3% of converter academies are sponsoring other schools. Many of them are, however, in groups which existed before they became academies as I pointed out here when Mr Gove was praising them as if the co-operation had only started once the highlighted schools became academies:

Ricky-Tarr's picture
Wed, 20/06/2012 - 16:46

Yes Janet, you have trotted out that next-to-meaningless 3% figure before. Gove has never said that co-operation only started upon conversion, all he has done has been to respond to those who imply that academization=atomisation that academies do and will co-operate in many diverse ways.

Janet Downs's picture
Thu, 21/06/2012 - 07:58

"...the outstanding schools that become Academies will be expected to sign-up in principle to support a weaker school in becoming an Academy."

From the Government Whip's Office when the Academy Bill was being rushed through Parliament. Downloadable from:

I admit that the Academies Bill was passed with the speed usually reserved for national emergencies, but I'm sure Gove was aware of the information being sent from the Whip's Office. Surely you're not suggesting that the Government was lying?

Janet Downs's picture
Thu, 21/06/2012 - 08:06

I've just re-read the Whip's office announcement: it didn't refer to Academies supporting "weaker" schools with help that might be needed (eg expertise, curriculum advice, professional development). No - it meant nudging them to become academies.

So the "support" that Gove envisages is not, as he keeps claiming, the professional support which was happening anyway (and for which he claims credit) but the "support" which encourages more schools to convert and have more "freedom".

The word "freedom", as Mr Gove uses it, has become debased.

Bob Wolfson's picture
Wed, 04/07/2012 - 10:21

The interesting development that LSN doesn't seem to have picked up on is who will sponsor the Academies that DfE has placed on the naughty step? There is a broad choice - will it be other local schools that have converted to Academy status as a result of their success, or will it be a national chain? In the absence of the former, DfE will press the latter. Now is a key moment for converter Academies to step up to the plate and support their local schools and prove the same commitment and moral purpose to all children that Haringey schools are showing. If they do not so, we will simply see the emergence of national chains as cross-boundary, commercial 'local' authorities.

Add new comment

Already a member? Click here to log in before you comment. Or register with us.