The Children Commissioner is right: children should have more say when choosing their teachers

Francis Gilbert's picture
For me, a key issue is not about giving parents choice of school, but providing children with real choices when they are actually in school. At the school where I currently teach we've always involved pupils in the process of choosing teachers, much in the way that the Children's Commissioner, Maggie Atkinson, advocates in the press yesterday. Dr Atkinson said: "Young people are a school's customers, and they see lots of different teaching styles over the course of a school career. Our research shows that they understand teaching is a challenging job which requires a wide range of skills from teachers - it is not just about their academic qualifications or how loudly they can shout." I would disagree with Atkinson that children are a school "customers" - the relationship between pupil and teacher is much more complex than that -- but I agree that on the whole children have a good understanding of what makes a good teacher, particularly if they've experienced good and bad teaching in their school careers.

I'd go further, children should have more say in schools as a whole. The Student Voice movement is an important one because it provides children with a chance to say what teachers they like and why, and what improvements they'd like to see in lessons. I've seen it go too far -- with pupils giving mock-Ofsteds using forms they don't understand -- but when it's done well and children speak in their "own language", it can be very valuable. Regularly surveying children's views on their lessons is a great idea; on the whole it shows what teachers are doing a great job and what ones need extra support to improve their lessons. As Dylan William points out it's not so much WHAT school a child goes to that's important, it's the teachers that they get there that's crucial.

We need to build and develop all mechanisms that help schools get better; I believe involving pupils in the recruitment process and making their voices heard is important to help schools improve.
Share on Twitter Share on Facebook

Be notified by email of each new post.

Add new comment

Already a member? Click here to log in before you comment. Or register with us.